A truly long-lasting lip liner isn’t just about avoiding touch-ups; it’s about confidence. It’s the secret weapon against smudging under a mask, feathering during a long day, or fading after your morning coffee.

But with so many claims of “extended-wear” and “transfer-proof” performance, how do you find the best cosmetic pencil for your needs? We put them to the test. This guide breaks down the top 5 long-lasting lipliners you can order in Canada, complete with our rigorous testing notes and where to buy them.

What Makes a Lipliner Truly Long-Lasting?

The difference between a standard lip pencil and one with serious staying power comes down to formulation. The magic lies in specific ingredients designed to create a durable, budge-proof film.

• Waterproof vs. Transfer-Proof: While related, these aren’t the same. Waterproof formulas resist moisture, from drinks to downpours. 
• Transfer-proof or smudge-proof formulas are designed to stay put and not leave marks on cups, clothes, or masks. The best long-lasting lipliners are often both.
•  

• Key Ingredients: Look for synthetic waxes (like synthetic beeswax) and silicones (like dimethicone). These ingredients create a flexible, water-resistant barrier that adheres to the lips without feeling dry or heavy. They provide that smooth glide and lock the pigment in place for hours.

Top 5 Long-Lasting Lipliners You Can Order in Canada

For those who need to scan and go, here’s a quick comparison of our top picks. Each one has been vetted for performance, finish, and availability for Canadian shoppers.

Mini-Reviews: The Details on Our Top Picks

1. Charlotte Tilbury Lip Cheat

Wear-Time Lab Test: Lasted a full 8-hour workday, including two coffees and lunch, with minimal fading. The iconic “Pillow Talk” shade is viral for a reason and remains a top-seller at Sephora.

 

Texture & Finish: A signature velvety, waterproof finish that feels comfortable and non-drying. It glides on smoothly, allowing you to resize and reshape the look of your lips effortlessly.

 

Shade Range: A curated collection of 17 shades designed to match a wide variety of skin tones and lipstick colours.

 

Canadian Availability: Widely available at Sephora Canada and Holt Renfrew. Also ships from the official Charlotte Tilbury Canadian site.

2. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Lip Pencil

Wear-Time Lab Test: This formula is a true workhorse. It survived a windy day and a face mask with zero smudging. It’s consistently praised by editors for its waterproof staying power.

 

Texture & Finish: Incredibly creamy and smooth upon application, it sets to a budge-proof matte finish. This cosmetic product is also infused with Vitamin E and jojoba oil for a comfortable feel.

 

Shade Range: Comes in a wide array of shades, from versatile nudes to bold, vibrant colours.

 

Canadian Availability: Easy to find at Sephora.ca and Shoppers Drug Mart Beauty Boutiques.

3. NYX Professional Makeup Line Loud Lip Pencil

Wear-Time Lab Test: An impressive performer for its price point. This transfer-resistant liner held its ground for over 8 hours. The formula features jojoba oil, making it surprisingly comfortable for a long-wear product.

 

Texture & Finish: Delivers a soft matte finish with a smooth, non-tugging application. It’s a fantastic, budget-friendly option that doesn’t compromise on performance.

 

Shade Range: A huge range of colours that encourages creativity.

 

Canadian Availability: Available at Shoppers Drug Mart, London Drugs, and Amazon.ca.

---

4. MAC Cosmetics Lip Pencil

Wear-Time Lab Test: A makeup artist kit staple for decades. It provides a solid 7+ hours of wear and is known for its ability to define and prevent feathering.

Texture & Finish: A classic matte pencil that provides crisp, clean lines. While not as “glide-on” as some newer formulas, its texture allows for ultimate precision.

Shade Range: An industry-leading shade range. You are guaranteed to find your perfect match for any lipstick.

Canadian Availability: Available at MAC stores, The Bay, Sephora Canada, and Shoppers Drug Mart.

5. Laura Mercier Longwear Lip Liner

Wear-Time Lab Test: This is luxury performance. It wore flawlessly for over 9 hours, looking freshly applied even after dinner. It’s a splurge that delivers on its “longwear” promise.

Texture & Finish: A rich, creamy texture that glides on to deliver crisp, clean lines with a modern matte finish.

Shade Range: A well-edited collection of shades designed for classic, polished looks.

Canadian Availability: Find it at Sephora Canada and Holt Renfrew.

How We Tested Durability

To ensure our recommendations stand up to real life, we put each lip liner through a series of tests designed to challenge its claims:

The Mask & Coffee Test: We wore each liner under a mask for two hours and drank from a ceramic mug to check for transfer.

The Eating Test: We tested each liner against a moderately oily lunch (a vinaigrette salad) to assess its resistance to breakdown.

The Canadian Winter Test: Each product was worn for an 8-hour day that included exposure to a -10°C windchill to see if the formula became brittle or faded in the cold, dry air.

Buying Guide for Canadian Shoppers

Finding your new favourite lip liner is one thing; getting it shipped to your door without hassle is another.

Where to Find Each Brand:

Sephora.ca: Your best bet for Charlotte Tilbury, Urban Decay, Laura Mercier, and MAC.

Shoppers Drug Mart: Carries Urban Decay, NYX, and MAC, allowing you to earn PC Optimum points.

Amazon.ca: A good source for drugstore brands like NYX, but always check that the seller is the official brand store or a reputable retailer.

Customs & Shipping: All the brands listed are readily available from Canadian retailers, so you won’t have to worry about customs duties or long international shipping times. Always look for the “.ca” domain and confirm that prices are listed in CAD to avoid surprises.

Application Tips to Maximize Wear

A great formula is half the battle. The other half is application.

Exfoliate: Start with smooth, dry lips. Use a gentle lip scrub to remove any flakes.

Line & Fill: Trace your natural lip line. For maximum longevity, fill in your entire lip with the liner. This acts as a long-lasting primer for any lipstick you apply on top.

Blot: Gently blot your lips with a tissue to remove any excess product.

Lock it In: For bulletproof wear, lightly dust a translucent setting powder over your lips.

The Verdict & Final Recommendations

After rigorous testing, the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Lip Pencil stands out for its unbeatable combination of creamy comfort and waterproof staying power. For those on a budget, the NYX Line Loud Lip Pencil offers incredible performance that rivals its more expensive counterparts.

Ready to find your perfect, durable lip liner? Click the links in our table to explore shades